The best mystery films of 1957

4 mystery films from 1957, ranked by a 0–100 score from IMDb ratings, critics, major awards and box office, compared with every film from the same year.

1. Witness for the Prosecution Score 76.8 · IMDb 8.4 · Tomatometer 100% · Metascore 76 · Drama, Mystery, Crime
2. Curse of the Demon Score 51.9 · IMDb 7.4 · Tomatometer 100% · Fantasy, Horror, Mystery
3. The Three Faces of Eve Score 44.0 · IMDb 7.2 · Tomatometer 93% · Metascore 58
4. Peyton Place Score 43.0 · IMDb 7.2 · Tomatometer 65% · Metascore 63