The best mystery films of 2009

69 mystery films from 2009, ranked by a 0–100 score from IMDb ratings, critics, major awards and box office, compared with every film from the same year.

  1. The Haunting in Connecticut Score 29.3 · IMDb 5.9 · Tomatometer 18% · Metascore 33 · Thriller, Horror
  2. The Door Score 29.3 · IMDb 6.6 · Fantasy, Thriller, Science Fiction
  3. Case 39 Score 29.2 · IMDb 6.2 · Tomatometer 22% · Metascore 25 · Horror, Mystery, Thriller
  4. The Limits of Control Score 29.1 · IMDb 6.2 · Tomatometer 43% · Metascore 41 · Crime, Mystery
  5. The Box Score 28.4 · IMDb 5.6 · Tomatometer 42% · Metascore 47 · Thriller, Science Fiction
  6. The Fourth Kind Score 27.4 · IMDb 5.9 · Tomatometer 18% · Metascore 34 · Mystery, Science Fiction, Thriller
  7. Across the Hall Score 27.3 · IMDb 5.8 · Thriller, Mystery
  8. Friday the 13th Score 26.8 · IMDb 5.5 · Tomatometer 26% · Metascore 34 · Horror, Thriller
  9. The Hills Run Red Score 26.2 · IMDb 5.4 · Tomatometer 50% · Horror, Thriller
  10. The Grudge 3 Score 25.9 · IMDb 4.6 · Mystery, Horror, Thriller