The best mystery films of 2009

68 mystery films from 2009, ranked by a 0–100 score from IMDb ratings, critics, major awards and box office, compared with every film from the same year.

  1. Beyond a Reasonable Doubt Score 20.3 · IMDb 5.8 · Tomatometer 7% · Metascore 35
  2. Blue Score 19.9 · IMDb 3.8
  3. The Cry of the Owl Score 19.6 · IMDb 5.9 · Tomatometer 11%
  4. Giallo Score 17.3 · IMDb 4.5
  5. Stolen Score 17.1 · IMDb 6.1 · Tomatometer 0% · Metascore 34
  6. Whiteout Score 15.1 · IMDb 5.5 · Tomatometer 7%
  7. Horsemen Score 12.5 · IMDb 5.5 · Tomatometer 17%
  8. S. Darko Score 10.3 · IMDb 3.6 · Tomatometer 13%