The best mystery films of 2016

60 mystery films from 2016, ranked by a 0–100 score from IMDb ratings, critics, major awards and box office, compared with every film from the same year.

  1. I Am the Pretty Thing That Lives in the House Score 25.5 · IMDb 4.6 · Tomatometer 62% · Metascore 68
  2. American Pastoral Score 24.8 · IMDb 6.1 · Tomatometer 24% · Metascore 43
  3. Tell Me How I Die Score 23.6 · IMDb 5.0
  4. A Kind of Murder Score 23.3 · IMDb 5.3 · Tomatometer 35% · Metascore 50
  5. Beyond the Woods Score 21.3 · IMDb 4.3
  6. Sacrifice Score 21.0 · IMDb 5.3 · Tomatometer 29% · Metascore 23
  7. The Forest Score 20.3 · IMDb 4.8 · Tomatometer 10% · Metascore 34
  8. The Bad Batch Score 19.1 · IMDb 5.2 · Tomatometer 45% · Metascore 62
  9. The Midnight Man Score 19.0 · IMDb 4.8 · Tomatometer 27%
  10. Autumn Lights Score 18.9 · IMDb 5.0 · Tomatometer 17% · Metascore 37